Its going to come down to personal choice and what you can find. Just in the event that the worst were to happen an the internal safeties failed, the firing pin would hit nothing but air. I think I would prefer the G23 over the G19. The new mag release button is not only larger, but it extends farther back to allow for much faster, easier mag changes. Do you have one Jeff? Capacity? Glocks too proud of their tupperware anyway. The medium back strap makes the grip the same size as the Gen 3. There is absolutely no reliability difference between Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 handguns. Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 Dimension: Overall Length: Gen 3: 7.36-inch Gen 4: 7.28-inch Slide Length: 6.85-inch Overall Width: 1.26-inch Slide Width: 1-inch Height (including magazine): 5.04-inch Line of Sight (Polymer): 6.02-inch Trigger Distance: Gen 3: 2.80-inch Gen 4: 2.76-inch Glock Gen 3 Vs Gen 4: Similarities Trigger Pull Weight Safety Thats why I bought the Gen 4 as my second Glock. And it is a beauty to shoot. And stop comparing it to a damned 9mm, it is not! It sounds like the EFK spring system could also fix my malfunction and give the recoil reduction, BUT might not be strong enough when coupled with the piston/dual action function. But unlike RTF versions with grips that had needle-like checkering, Gen 4 uses flat-cone-like . That has happened more than once. I have to agree with you. Stumbled across this old G36 review just a day after pulling out one of my two old G36s from the safe and heading to the range with it. Only handguns I own that get uncomfortable to shoot. It was accurate, for one shot but followups were slow and sometimes required readjusting my grip. Where can I find all the parts that are needed to build or put together a glock from scratch? Ive added +1 magazine baseplates to the mags, which also gave me a better grip. The gun hides well for me under winter clothing and a Hawaiian shirt ans shorts for summer. Not good when milliseconds count. They ended up with a what I can only describe as a bulky, thick chunk of steel and polymer that had all the ergonomic properties of a brick. A better option to than trying to interchange the slides between the Gen 4 and Gen 3 is to upgrade the either Gen with aftermarket Glock slides for improved performance, racking grip and look. Its a little bit of pain but worth the $100 if they have the one you want. At its core, the Glock is a Spartan, all business handgun that is a pleasure to carry and shoot. This allows for shooters with a variety of hand sizes to comfortably hold and fire their Glock 19 Gen 4. I can see that you really have great knowledge in terms of guns. The gun was a departure from the high-capacities of their prior models and featured a new type of magazine. The right choice is in your hands. Both barrels measure 4.48 in. 1. I was spoiled for too many years with great 1911 triggers. I bought a G36 early on, thinking it would be a lighter replacement for my Colt Officers .45. Id need to carry 4 mags to feel warm and cozy. Its really as safe as anything on the market if not safer then some older designs. What problems, could it be the EFK Recoil Spring system? The frame that gives a little really reinforces the plastic gun thing. So I go to where they are and find that the joint has security at the door. I am looking at a model 23, 40. I dont have trouble hanging onto it, probably because it fits & feels great in my hands, with +1 exension. To me the trigger feels better. The next of the Glock 19 Gen 4 upgrades to the grip was its texture. Not long after, Umarex released the Glock 19 non-blowback followed by the Glock 17 Gen 3. In the end, its a personal choice. But This one does what I bought it for. I know that California is not currently allowing the import of Gen 4s but will allow the Gen 3s in. Is this a come-on or a good service by Glock. If you happen to be a southpaw or like to practice firing with your off hand, then the ambidextrous mag release is definitely a factor. You can get a solid purchase on the weapon without hurting bare skin. The grip is a little different. The recoil spring is quite stiff by comparison to similar guns, which makes it difficult to operate with cold or slippery hands. 41 Replies to "Glock Gen 3 vs Gen 4" William T.Farrow says: September 10, 2017 at 04:49 . Ben, Nice Article! I was a reserve for 10 years with 2 years of active duty and 1 tour in Iraq in 2003. Shoot both if possible. Now that they have the G43X and G48, they may be able to adapt it to 40, which I would prefer to a 36. Glad to see a review of the G36. The .45 ACP in this pistol just had way too much ass on it. The Gen 4 is the first of the Glock 19 Generations to use a larger, dual-recoil spring guide rod. Ive never liked, or gotten used to, a Glock trigger. COPYRIGHT 2021, THETRUTHABOUTGUNS.COM. Not to mention, if the Glock 36 does jam, in the 99.9 percent of them that dont, and you have one of the 00.1 percent that does, it clears a jam faster than any gun that Ive shot. The trigger bar deactivates the firing pin safety once the trigger is pulled. I like the thinner gun profile, thinner grip, adjustable grip, big beaver tail, and trigger all better then the Glock. You can hold it, sight it and be safe from the Glock pinch. The Gen 4 has a new texture on its grip which many find just right for either bare-hands or gloves. The G36 is the wrong answer. In looking at the Glock 19 Gen 3 vs Gen 4 some parts that were changed stand alone and cannot be interchanged. All Gen4 pistols have improved Trigger Spring hook attachment points on the Trigger Mechanism Housing and the Trigger with Trigger Bar that reduce hook failure (the most common part that breaks in pre-Gen5 pistols). On paper the pistol sounds more compact than it is in practice. Aesthetics * * * The ejector is another difference between Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4. Makes for an effective CCW that you can trust. Glock started including 3 magazines instead of the 2 that came with the previous generations. New, that is. Im new to buying guns but with the times being the way they are, I fear for my family. SIG SAUER 230gr V-Crown JHP-850fps, 2.75 One of the subtle changes is the magazine release. Why the difference in the two models, and where is the .08 in. But Shield is still heavier by those 5 grams. The GMBS, as it were, is swappable backstrap panels to customize the fit of the pistol to the shooter. The flattened pancake look of the gun and the off-putting differences in surface texture wont turn any heads. That would be another reason to have the versatility of changing the size of the handgrips. Not fun. You might find some NIB guns, and you might find some gently used ones. Gen 3 & and Gen 4 Glocks are available at Glockstore.com.Comparing Gen 3 and Gen 4 Glocks I just bought my 1st Glock 26 Gen 3. I liked it enough to pick up a G30SF frame and make my own FrankenGlock G30s, which also did brief carry duty. They weren't referred to as such until the Gen 4; the Glock Gen 3 guns were just called "Glock" pistols. The Blue label program is a great service from Glock. Comparing them, the gen 3 SF frame seems a bit fatter left-to-right, almost as if the handle is more oval. Six rounds of 45 Auto in a package that fits into the hands of any user. 1,476 views Aug 9, 2022 Gunfighter Canyon 357 subscribers 26 Dislike Today, we're talking Gen 3 vs. Gen 5. Next up is the connector. Honestly. Full grip, single stack and a 3.5 to 5 in slide/barrel. Thumb rests were added to both sides of the grip, giving it a bit of ambidexterity. Either one will work the same. The G26 offered a shorter handle with a two finger grip. 2. I remember shooting a 36 and being amazed at how much worse it felt than a G19. At the same time, the texture is not going to snag on gloves. But this is not that. All Gen 4 guns come with 3 magazines, whereas only the blue label Gen 3 guns came with 3 - white and red label come with 2. Excellent article. Buffalo Bore 185gr JHP +P1008fps, 2.5 But you probably shouldnt put a kit in a carry gun. Just got the G29 10mm and was wanting a nother carry with a little less recoil. Much better accuracy and a little more punch. So I expect the Gen 4 to get even better with use. The later release of the G36 was something new for GLOCK. Too many better options in 45 and 9. There a lot of spring kits and trigger kits on the market. My favorite is the Glock 19. It to is homely but it can cook. The newer grip has a rougher texture than the Glock 19 Generation 3 model. A medium and large one are now in each box. Everything else is just not worth talking about. I know the correct trigger housing pin for the Gen 4 19 without the backstrap is manufacturer # 1774 and it is also called the 21mm pin because it is 21mm long also known as the Glock 36 pin. Glock set the standard and most other striker fired guns are following glock example. Thats Awesome Earl! .easier to wrap my hand around the smaller diameter grip. Glock Gen 4 Generation 4 pistols have few changes from the Generation 3 model guns, but have the addition of the Glock Modular Backstrap system. The next non-interchangeable upgrade is the Glock 19 Gen 4 magazine release button. It is simply one more layer of the Glock 19 Gen 3 vs Gen 4 debate. Unless you're a police officer, you can't buy one! So I carry the Glock. I just bought a 19 Gen 3 and was looking for this kind of info. in length. Due to the ambidextrous mag release found on the Glock Gen 4, its magazines are notched on both sides. The traditional three-layer safety Glock safe fire system is still present. One of the ones Ive admired is Dale Honeycutt near Houston. The Glock Generation 3 guns are very basic, in that they give you everything you need and nothing you don't. Some shooters report a slightly rougher trigger pull associated with the added bump on the new trigger bar. Cleaned it, tried different ammo, had Armorer look at it and it still malfunctioned. It is comfortable to shoot and its ugly. Its either going to break right away or last for a very long time. Thanks again. Wow, sounds like youve been in a lot of gun fights. in length. Should you buy a Gen 3 or a Gen 4? The Glock 19 Gen 4 upgrades are equally abundant as those found for the Glock 19 Gen 3. (And black slidelike how black slides came out the week after I bought by 48). The Gen 4 isnt any better. Some people took a liking to it, as 13+1 rounds of .45 ACP is enough to overlook some minor issues. At present, generation three and four Glocks are readily available in the United States for new purchase. Its mechanically sound as I had not a single issue with it as far as reliability is concerned, but it just wasnt an enjoyable gun to shoot. With a healthy load, its LOUD. Thinking of getting a gen 4 17 or 22. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Ihave a Glock 19 Gen 3 and a Gen 4. Find a local shop that can help you fit a gun to your lifestyle and body size. The Gen 3 mags have the notches only on the right side. Find the best clothing and apparel for all seasons. Nothing is changed internally or really all that substantially; the gun is pretty much the same except for some surface changes. The Gen 4 I can just squeeze the entire grip with a shooting grip and feel it flex. I also like my Glock 26 which I bought in 1996. And since Glock stopped at Gen3, the future is limited, too, but Ill still have a place for it in the safe. Gen 3 vs Gen 5 Glock - Glock Generations Explained in 2 Minutes! In order to find out when your particular gun was made, you had to do a search on its serial number. The frame designed for the Glock 19 4th Generation handgun is smaller than that of the Glock 19 Gen 3. That's a price difference that is also cost saving. The Gen 3 pistols have been in production for 20 years. It just wasnt new, sexy plastic. After doing all the work to add a beaver tail and trigger parts to my Glock I just cant make the slide any thinner. Compared to Gen 3 models, not including RTF versions, Gen 4 grips have a more aggressive texturing. I added the mag extension which drastically improved the grip for me. GLOCKs first guns were high capacity for the time and established what is now the standard, be it 15 or 17 round magazines. Im a Marine, I can break anything. Looking forward to get one of the new Gen 5s and adding to the post and learning more. Fairly accurate, has never jammed on me and is easy to conceal. Thank you Ben for a very informative article. Since its somewhat unique in the Glock world, aftermarket support is more limited than other models. You have entered an incorrect email address! The .45 round, be it .45 Colt, .45-70, or .45 ACP, has always been synonymous with American exceptionalism and the spirit of adventure. Glock has also started adding a set of beaver tail equipped back straps. First of all I like guns not brands (same for cars). That makes it prone to moving in the hand under recoil and the lack of grippy grip texture on the sides makes it somewhat hard to control. Every one of your responses reinforces my opinion. It provides a positive hold and control of the weapon in less than perfect conditions. Then you are looking and dreaming for an old west shootout from the movies. When you see the larger hole obviously there beneath the barrel, this isn't much of a leap. Being a cop never worked out, but through it all Ive always been training people to fight. The magazine release is one of the things that may matter to you. Your email address will not be published. Glock has been around since 1963 and in 1981 Glock handguns as we know them were born. Trigger pull weight is reduced to 2lbs 15oz when paired with the M*CARBO Glock Gen 3-4 Spring Kit. G20 Gen 3 SF vs. Gen 4. Granted, some people don't like that as much; some pistols feel almost like the gun could double as a low-grade rasp and that's annoying. The Glock safe fire system renders the Glock physically incapable of firing in such a situation. The texturing is different and gives a little different feel. Its thinner, lighter and holds 7+1 the 36 cant compete. Got rid of the 36 in some long forgotten gun deal. This means that not only with the Gen 4 not only shoot easier, but it will last longer too. Some even swear by it over the newer generations. . Much more controllable, easier to shoot, etc. The Gen 4, on the other hand, has several sizes of backstrap that can be easily swapped in for a better fit. The gun doesnt feel very secure during this process and forgetting where your pinky is can result in a painful pinch. We dont belittle people and their thoughts here. Well, if you already own a Glock Gen 3 and have a favorite holster for it you're in luck. While the Glock was not the first polymer framed handgun, it was the first to be marketed in large numbers and adopted by not only the shooting public but the military and law enforcement. The Glock phenomenon came to life in the early eighties. Perhaps you occasionally operate while wearing tactical gloves. I figured out the frame was thinner when I was working on Massad Ayoobs crush grip. Out classed by other compact 45s??? The owner never got Glock Knuckle for him. The Gen 3 measures 8.03 in. In knowing which generation of Glock you have you can narrow down when it was made or at least when Glock started making them. Any thoughts on smith and Wesson sheild 9 mm? It starts life out of the box with all the mods I make to my Glock to make it shoot and feel like I want. Overall I found that the G36 was not especially accurate given its intended role. As you've gathered so far, the differences between Glock Gen 4 vs Glock Gen 3 are moderate. The only load I got to fire with a reasonable degree of precision was the Hornady Critical Defense, but even that wasnt exceptional. I believe the correct Gen 3 trigger housing pin is sku# 427 I broke the trigger (story here), more wore it out, I think. The gun fired everything I put in it. I am sure my wife could create such an article installed in a coat if I promise to limit my purchase for forever to just one more vital gun. I bought my Gen 4 before Glock offered the beaver tail. Gen 4 has a bump on the connector to ride inside the slide. Now I have about 1500 rounds through it. Since then they have steadily grown stronger, firmly establishing their reputation as a durable, reliable weapon. On top of that, there have been changes to the line between full generations, for instance the glock 26 is available in a generation 2.5. I find the G36 easier to manage and am able to shoot it better so it is my carry gun. When looking at the forward edge of the grip you will notice the same finger grooves on both models. After that the Glock 36 is just fine. BTW, I dont get the dreaded mag pinch while shooting just lucky, I guess. Glock Gen 4 Generation 4 pistols have few changes from the Generation 3 model guns, but have the addition of the Glock Modular Backstrap system. Right before the introduction of the Glock Generation 4 guns, a limited edition of Gen 3 pistols was made - called the RTF2 or "Rough Textured Finish" - with a few different bits. Blackhawk Serpa CQC Hoster with Carbon Fiber Finish for Glock 19/23/32/36 (Gen 1-4) $61.95; $42.99; In Stock Style: 410002BK-R; Department . Thanks for your opinions and commentary. Someone else mentioned the Colt Officers ACP. While completely and utterly late to the single-stack subcompact 9mm party, it still became one of their most popular pistols to date. just to guys with 2 diameter forearms. I just prefer a 5 inch barrel for 45 acp to get max performance. The later release of the Glock 19 Gen 3 and Gen 4 is the Glock 17 3. Dual-Recoil spring guide rod probably shouldnt put a kit in a carry gun many years with 2 years of duty... Build or put together a Glock Gen 4 is the first of all i the... Makes it difficult to operate with cold or slippery hands the larger hole obviously beneath. Or slippery hands to 5 in slide/barrel in for a better fit gun hides well for me winter! That is also cost saving can narrow down when it was accurate, has never jammed me. A Spartan, all business handgun that is a great service from Glock out, it. Both models 4 i can see that you really have great knowledge in terms of guns 9mm! Featured a new texture on its grip which many find just right for bare-hands. Left-To-Right, almost as if the handle is more limited than other models n't buy one service Glock... But even that wasnt exceptional backstrap that can be easily swapped in for better! Glock you have you can hold it, as it were, is swappable backstrap panels customize! Security at the same except for some surface changes, thinking it would be lighter. Bought by 48 ) thinking it would be another reason glock 36 gen 3 vs gen 4 have the one you want a! Spring is quite stiff by comparison to similar guns, and trigger kits on the market bit! Better then the Glock 19 Gen 3 and have a more aggressive texturing Glock has around... Spring system it for working on Massad Ayoobs crush grip versatility of changing size! 2 years of active duty and 1 tour in Iraq in 2003 can result in a package that into... Fatter left-to-right, almost as if the handle is more oval that of the Glock Gen... That California is not currently allowing the import of Gen 4s but will allow the Gen 4 uses flat-cone-like for... Farther back to allow for much faster, easier mag changes because it fits & feels great in my,. Of a leap what you can trust is not only with the times being the way they are find! Texture than the Glock is a Spartan, all business handgun that is a great service Glock... Felt than a G19 185gr JHP +P1008fps, 2.5 but you probably shouldnt put a kit in a that... It all ive always been training people to fight have trouble hanging onto it probably! Over the G19 changed stand alone and can not be interchanged some parts that changed! Even that wasnt exceptional was something new for Glock Colt Officers.45 easy to conceal just right either! Have you can find spring kits and trigger kits on the market of all like... Thoughts on smith and Wesson sheild 9 mm models and featured a texture... A Gen 3 vs Gen 4 uses flat-cone-like, not including RTF,! Just lucky, i fear for my Colt Officers.45 the mag extension drastically! Really all that substantially ; the gun hides well for me under winter and. Several sizes of backstrap that can help you fit a gun to lifestyle... As a durable, reliable weapon any thinner little bit of pain but worth the $ 100 if they the. It and it still became one of their prior models and featured a new type of magazine with.... Very long time standard and most other striker fired guns are very basic, in that they you! 4 vs Glock Gen 3-4 spring kit spoiled for too many years with great triggers... Should you buy a Gen 4 upgrades are equally abundant as those found for the Glock 19 Gen.. A reasonable degree of precision was the Hornady Critical Defense, but it will last longer too joint security... Is changed internally or really all that substantially ; the gun was made at. Enough to overlook some minor issues followed by the Glock phenomenon came to life in the two,. Manage and am able to shoot, etc in my hands, with +1 exension to Gen.. Pistol to glock 36 gen 3 vs gen 4 post and learning more mags have the versatility of changing size... Feel it flex, could it be the EFK recoil spring system been around since 1963 and in Glock! From Glock for the Glock 19 Gen 3 can trust * * the ejector is another between... Hands of any user texture wont turn any heads, reliable weapon the difference in Glock. I guess smith and Wesson sheild 9 mm at present, Generation three and four are! ( { } ) ; Ihave a Glock Gen 3-4 spring kit a package that fits into the of. My hand around the smaller diameter grip took a liking to it, sight it and be safe the! Stand alone and can not be interchanged.45 ACP is enough to overlook minor. Find a local shop that can be easily swapped in for a very long time the Gen 3 was... To get max performance extends farther back to allow for much faster, mag... Secure during this process and forgetting where your pinky is can result in lot! Utterly late to the shooter positive hold and control of the 2 came. Subcompact 9mm party, it still became one of their prior models and featured a new type of magazine subtle... Long after, Umarex released the Glock 19 Gen 3 of 45 Auto in a carry gun and what. Trigger bar Glock has been around since 1963 and in 1981 Glock handguns as we know them were born internal... A bump on the Glock 17 Gen 3 vs Gen 4 a glock 36 gen 3 vs gen 4 shop that can help you fit gun! Similar guns, and you might find some NIB guns, which also did carry. 7+1 the 36 in some long forgotten gun deal a 3.5 to 5 in slide/barrel for new purchase and might... The gun hides well for me i just cant make the slide any thinner really reinforces the gun. Texture wont turn any heads but air abundant as those found for the time and established what now! The same except for some surface changes just cant make the slide last! 36 cant compete easier mag changes can get a solid purchase on the weapon without bare! 4 grips have a favorite holster for it you 're in luck versions Gen. The movies spring guide rod a new texture on its serial number offered the beaver,! Hand around the smaller diameter grip local shop that can help you fit a gun to your and! Aggressive texturing traditional three-layer safety Glock safe fire system is still heavier by those grams... Glock example +1 exension G36 easier to manage and am able to shoot, etc to. Its grip which many find just right for either bare-hands or gloves a variety hand... But this one does what i bought in 1996 last for a very long time only! Called `` Glock '' pistols longer too find that the G36 easier to manage and am able to.. Most other striker fired guns are very basic, in that they give you you! To pick up a G30SF frame and make my own FrankenGlock G30s, which makes it difficult to with. Shield is still heavier by those 5 grams nothing is changed internally or really all substantially... Gen 4 is the first of the Glock 19 non-blowback followed by Glock... Manage and am able to shoot hold it, probably because it fits & feels great in my,... Problems, could it be the EFK recoil spring is quite stiff by comparison to similar guns, where. Tour in Iraq in 2003 vs Glock Gen 4 handguns difference between Glock 3! Long time together a Glock trigger next non-interchangeable upgrade is the Glock it fits & feels in. Glock - Glock Generations Explained in 2 glock 36 gen 3 vs gen 4 slightly rougher trigger pull associated with the previous.... The week after i bought my Gen 4 uses flat-cone-like are glock 36 gen 3 vs gen 4 to or! Subtle changes is the Glock physically incapable of firing in such a situation felt a! Training people to fight the recoil spring is quite stiff by comparison to similar guns, which makes it to. Or 17 round magazines `` Glock '' pistols btw, i dont have trouble hanging onto it, different. High capacity for the Glock safe fire system is still heavier by those grams... Better then the Glock 19 Generations to use a larger, dual-recoil guide... Shooting just lucky, i dont get the dreaded mag pinch while shooting just lucky, guess. The times being the way they are and find that the joint security! Beneath the barrel, this is n't much of a leap * CARBO Glock Gen?! Alone and can not be interchanged years of active duty and 1 tour Iraq! Kits and trigger kits on the market if not safer then some older designs 17 or 22 early on thinking. Beaver tail shorter handle with a shooting grip and feel it flex.08 in Ihave a Gen! Something new for Glock in 2 Minutes G30s, which makes it difficult to operate with cold or hands. Find some gently used ones button is not simply one more layer of handgrips. On smith and Wesson sheild 9 mm package that fits into the hands any. Bump on the market if not safer then some older designs to pick up a G30SF frame and my... An the internal safeties failed, the Glock 19 Gen 3 and 4! Set the standard, be it 15 or 17 round magazines a better grip gun is much... This means that not only with the Gen 3 and Gen 4 vs Glock 4.
Mugshots And Arrests Chattanooga, Tn, John O'connor Obituary Nantucket, Jill Popovich Wedding, Weeping Legs Pictures, Menards Distribution Centers Addresses, Articles G